Extraordinarily thorough and responsive ... austerely elegant ... a distinguished essay in cultural history and critical theory.
Times Literary Supplement
This is a book to be grateful for.
Criticism
A richly informing and provocative work of intellectual history ... Mulhern marshals his evidence with a rare power of argument and a scrupulous fairness of coverage.
British Book News
<i>The Moment of 'Scrutiny'</i> is an important and valuable book ... written with intensity and intelligence.
The Nation
This is a valuable book for anyone interested in literary criticism and the history and philosophy of culture.
Choice
A cogent and incisive study of culture and politics in England from the post-World War I era to the early 1950s.
Antioch Review
Very welcome and important ... the book is at once indispensable.
Guardian
Beginning with an analysis of Scrutiny's emergence in the complex historical conditions of inter-war England, Francis Mulhern goes on to recount the work of the journal. Elucidating the logic of of the project that it served, he demonstrates its coherence of purpose, while at the same time tracing the successive mutations that its discourse underwent in the changing politico-cultural conjunctures of its lifetime. A final chapter situates Scrutiny comparatively in the context of early-twentieth-century European thought, considers its specific function in the cultural history of mid-century England and the enigmas of its last years and after-life, and moves finally to an assessment of its significance today.