Godden and Irvine provide a rich and learned edition that should supersede both full and partial older versions.
Nicole Guenther Discenza, The Review of English Studies
The editors have done a very fine job
Review of English Studies
marks a major advance on what has sometimes seemed the blocked road to understanding Anglo-Saxon literary history
Tom Shippey, Times Literary Supplement
opens up new research possibilities by its thorough and detailed presentation of the first vernacular translation of one of the most influential texts of the Middle Ages ... sets the standard for future editions of medieval texts, not in the least by illustrating how detailed and thorough an edition of a text can (and should) be.
Thijs Porck, English Studies