The sheer scope and erudition of these pages is stunning ... an imaginative tour de force.
- Terry Eagleton, Guardian
Provocative, original ... a powerful testimony to the unending dialogue between the present and the past that is the essence and excitement of history.
- David Cannadine, Observer
A stunning collection ... humane, optimistic, multi-textured, ever-meandering but always sparkling ... One of the finest and-paradoxically-most quintessentially English historians of our time.
- Ben Pimlott, Independent on Sunday
A magnificent and irreplaceable collection.
- John Gray, New Statesman
A provocative lens into both the remote and the near British past.
Publishers Weekly
Deeply researched, intelligently argued, lovingly presented, thoroughly excitable and immensely stimulating ... [Samuel is] as comfortable with seventeenth-century sectarians as with Victorian nonconformists, as familiar with the townlands of Ireland as the streets of London.
- John Gillis, Left History
A rich fund of subversive ideas.
- Daniel Johnson, The Times