The key strength of the monograph lies in its ability to stimulate novel perspectives regarding the unified yet distinct nature of figurative language and its diverse manifestations. In sum, <i>Figuring out Figuration</i> offers a variety of intriguing proposals that will appeal to different types of readers.
- Špela Antloga, University of Maribor, in Metaphor and the Social World 13:2 (2023).,
In summary, the authors strike a perfect balance between tradition and innovation. Their deep knowledge of existing approaches and the application of the pragma-cognitive perspective allows them to create a concept that is undoubtedly innovative but, above all, coherent. Their achievement is worthy of deep admiration, given the nature of the subject matter.
- Dana Kratochvílová, Charles University, in Review of Cognitive Linguistics 22:1 (2024),
Peña-Cervel and Ruiz de Mendoza's book, which has an impressive bibliography, is a daring and robust step in the invaluable project of developing a modern, cognitivist-oriented trope framework. The authors admirably dare to adapt, or even by-pass, older views to explain how the various tropes need to be positioned vis-a-vis each other. One of the strengths of their approach is that they provide concrete, applicable criteria to distinguish between related tropes. Their categorizations and subcategorizations are meticulously precise.[...] The framework provided in this monograph will also be beneficial in sorting out which tropes can be combined [...]. Moreover, it can help making progress in another challenging task, one that naturally flows from accepting that tropes reflect cognitive processes: charting how tropes can be expressed in other media than language. Other media (pictures, film, music), have structure, but not grammar, and this has serious consequences for how one can identify tropical patterns in them. In turn, cognitive linguists, whose perspective is necessarily limited by the fact that they are…well, linguists, may profit from the work that is beginning to be done by cognitivist scholars working on tropes in non-verbal and multimodal media.
- Charles Forceville, University of Amsterdam, in Journal of Pragmatics 202 (2022).,