Townshend's book is a comprehensive, thoroughly researched, clearly written, quite convincing, and powerfully argued answer—at last—to the incompleteness and polarization in this array of scholarship... Gothic Antiquity, then, is a masterpiece of its kind: densely packed because of its scholarly rigor but also a pleasure to read because of its lucid style and its well-crafted, logical organization... All future research on and teaching about the Gothic's heyday in England, the rise of Romanticism, and the beginnings of the Victorian era, in writing and architecture, will need to take account of this monumental achievement in aesthetic, literary, and historical scholarship.
Jerrold E. Hogle, University of Arizona, The Wordsworth Circle
Gothic Antiquity is essentially a literary study, but enriched by a clear understanding of the antiquarian engagement with the mediaeval past and its relics, and of the development of philosophical ideas of associationist aesthetics that together underpinned the rediscovery of the Gothic. It provides a detailed and useful summary of a substantial number of Gothic novels, their plots and their authors, and shows how the genre evolved from Walpole to Radcliffe and Charlotte Smith and Sophia Lee, on to 'Monk' Lewis and Maturin and beyond. Above all, it charts a sea-change in popular taste from the Augustan and classical certainties of the early eighteenth century, to an early nineteenth-century world where the head of a landed family might well re-build his seat in a Gothic style to demonstrate his family's antiquity (a successful City merchant might do the same to demonstrate his family's aspirations).
Beckford Journal