`both books, and in particular the collection of essays, do pull together what is currently known about Whewell and this can only act as a stimulus to further study'
Victorian Studies
`the first time the results have been brought together in this way ... wide-ranging and no more collection of pieces d'occasion'
J.W. Burrows, Times Literary Supplement
'this book succeeds like no other in synthesizing the full scope of his diverse historical influence ... This volume is a valuable contribution to the understanding of 19th-century intellectual life and should be acquired by libraries supporting a curriculum in the history and philosophy of science. Level: upper-division undergraduate and up.'
L.C. Archie, Lander College, Choice, Nov '91
'well-balanced, readable, and insightful study of Whewell's study of science ... This critical appraisal of Whewell's philosophy of science is highly recommended for all college libraries and is indispensable for history of science programs.'
L.C. Archie, Lander College, Choice, Feb '92
'It brings together thirteen accomplished Whewell scholars to explore the context and content of his prodigious life and work. If one wishes to work historically into the Whewell text, one can do no better than begin with Composite Portrait'
Don McNally, Pascal Centre, Ontario, History of Science, Volume 25, 1992