<p><b>Praise for <i>The Allure of Elsewhere</i></b></p><p>“This inspirational travelogue from Babine recounts a trip she took in her mid-30s to connect with her roots. . . . It’s a moving account from a restless questioner.”—<i>Publishers Weekly</i></p><p>“Babine’s adventure celebrates life in the margins: not just as a woman camping alone, but as a woman in her mid-thirties who defies the usual categorical boxes . . . It’s my chosen ‘vacation read.’”<b>—<i>Tupelo Quarterly </i></b></p><p>“A truly fascinating and heartwarming travelogue that beautifully points us in bold directions, reminding us that sometimes in order to feel connected—it can also be brilliant and delightful to travel alone.”<b>—Aimee Nezhukumatathil, author of <i>World of Wonders</i></b></p><p>“What a pleasure to travel with Karen Babine, along highways and logging roads, from campsite to campsite, through time and deep into history. <i>The Allure of Elsewhere</i> showcases a love of geography and genealogy, close family and distant ancestors, fierce independence, solitude, storytelling, and the crafting of a life. Under Babine’s deft attention, places come alive, the dead reanimate, time folds in on itself until centuries feel tangible. ‘It’s all connected,’ she writes, ‘even if we cannot recognize the ways in a particular moment.’ <i>The Allure of Elsewhere</i> shows us how.”<b>—Michele Morano, author of <i>Like Love</i></b></p><p>“<i>The Allure of Elsewhere</i> is a beautiful unraveling of family history through self-exploration. Just as a winding road reveals its secrets one at a time, Karen Babine takes us through the twists and turns of a complex genealogy and her own place within it. She weaves the story of her chosen solo lifestyle with generations prior who lived the opposite while examining how their history lives not just in our memories, but in our bones.”<b>—Heather Anderson, author of <i>Thirst: 2600 Miles to Home</i></b></p><p><b><br /></b></p><p><b>Praise for <i>All the Wild Hungers</i></b></p><p>“Profound . . . Anyone who has experienced a family member’s struggle with cancer will be stabbed by recognition throughout this book . . . In the end, the overriding hunger referred to in this lovely book’s title is the hunger for life . . . Praise, sympathy and thanks to Babine, who has given us this ode, lament and meditation.” <b><i>—Minneapolis Star Tribune</i></b></p><p>“Babine exudes a passion that is inseparable from action . . . She is cooking against cancer . . . <i>All the Wild Hungers</i> is composed, in both senses of the word, calm, and put together with care.” <b><i>—Los Angeles Review of Books</i></b></p><p>“Transportive and vivid . . . Babine’s writing brims with tenderness—for her family, her home, and the food she prepares—warming readers’ hearts.” <b><i>—Publishers Weekly</i></b></p><p>“For the author, food sustains like a lifeline or even a bloodline. . . . [Babine] continues to navigate her way through extraordinary challenges with ordinary comforts, finding poetry in the everyday. Reading this quiet book should provide the sort of balm for those in similar circumstances.” <b><i>—Kirkus</i></b></p><p>“A lush gem of a book, both heartbreaking and heart-making. Karen Babine’s language is the plush dough she kneads, her observations as elastic as gluten bubbles. By the book’s conclusion you will become a child again, standing on a chair to peer into the pot, not wanting the process of making—of cooking, of understanding, of as she says, ‘consuming the knowing’—to ever end.”<b>—Amy Thielen, author of Give a Girl a Knife</b></p><p>“In this beautiful and haunting book, Karen Babine leads us into the kitchen and cooks healing meals for her mother and herself. With humor and imagination, she names each of her cast iron pots, reclaimed from thrift stores, and simmers the elements of grief and longing, hope and love, with acceptance, insight, and wisdom.”<b>—Beth Dooley, author of <i>In Winter’s Kitchen: Growing Roots and Breaking Bread in the Northern Heartland</i></b></p>
“A truly fascinating and heartwarming travelogue that beautifully points us in bold directions.”—Aimee Nezhukumatathil, author of World of Wonders
One woman’s cross-country journey to explore the hold family history has on our lives, and the power of new stories to shape what lies ahead.
In her mid-thirties and happily single, Karen Babine hitches up her tiny Scamp camper and sets out with her two unenthusiastic cats, Galway and Maeve, on a journey from her home in Minnesota to Nova Scotia to explore the place where her French-Acadian ancestors settled in North America some four centuries ago.
As the miles roll by, she wonders: “Why do we carry this need to belong to an established history? What happens when that can’t—or shouldn’t—happen?” The road reveals more questions than answers about her history, identity, and belonging, about the responsibilities of stories and silence, about her life choices as a solo woman, and what it means to be driven by both a strong sense of kinship to a very close-knit family on one hand and a deep desire for independence on the other.
Capturing the joy, freedom, and powerful pull of the open road, The Allure of Elsewhere is about the stories we’re told, the stories we tell, and the way those stories make us who we are, often in surprising ways. Intimate, curious, and candid, written with wry wit and warmth, this is a courageous and inspiring memoir.
INTRODUCTION
The year I turned thirty, I was teaching in Ohio,
and as was my habit, I went home to Minnesota for the
summer break. My sister Kristi was getting married. Just for
fun, Dad drove three hours south to meet me in Minneapolis,
because I wanted to look at campers, and when you live in
northern Minnesota you do things like drive three hours just
for fun, and we worked our way up through the various RV
dealers along Highway 10 north toward my hometown of
Nevis. We finally ended up in Backus, at the Scamp factory,
where they make the small, bulbous fiberglass campers that
I’d wanted for years, maybe even half my life if I wanted to
count back. Scamps are one of several kinds of lightweight
molded fiberglass campers, and somebody once told me that
the cult of Scamp is just as annoying as the cult of Apple:
once you get one, you can’t stop talking about it, and you
never go back. You’re Scamp for life. They’re not wrong.
But things felt different that summer.
Maybe it was the cliché of my approaching thirtieth
birthday in October.
Maybe it was something about turning thirty cutting
down on people asking when I’d get married or have kids,
convinced I’d change my mind as my thirties approached,
but I’d still say I might find Mr. Right, but he’s still going to
have to live next door.
Maybe it was that our concept of family and what that
looked like was changing, all in good ways. Kristi married
Mike that summer, they’d bought a house, and my young-
est sister Kim moved in, the three of them creating an in-
tentional community based on the idea that if and when
Kim partnered, he’d move in, rather than her moving out.
My tight-knit family was getting tighter. When my niece
was born, I was incredibly grateful for Skype collapsing the
distance between Ohio and Minnesota, even as Kristi’s dog
would look at my face on the screen, then worriedly look
under the table, wondering where the rest of my body was.
My parents moved down to the Twin Cities when they re-
tired to be a much closer part of their grandchildren’s lives
instead of retiring to the Cabin in northern Minnesota as
they had intended. We were still close, but there’s a dif-
ference between visiting family and being close enough to
show up for dinner on a whim. And I was still in Ohio, or
Nebraska, or North Dakota, and not there.
Through my twenties, it was clear just how much the
world is not set up for solo people, not emotionally or logisti-
cally. I came to dread the singles’ table at friends’ weddings,
the kids’ table at the California Grandparents’ house, even
as Kristi and Mike were permitted to sit at the adults’ table
because they were married and I wasn’t, even though I was
two years older. There weren’t enough people at home to need
a kids’ table, so it was strange to be separated from the older
generations until I’d achieved something I didn’t know I was
supposed to be pursuing. Everything about the world told me
my life would only have value once I married, once I had kids,
once I grew up, once I settled down. By the time I turned thirty,
I was really tired of it. In August, back in Ohio to start a new
school year, I found my perfect Scamp for sale in Cleveland
and within a few days, it was sitting in my driveway.
In the years before the Scamp, working toward what
it meant to be a solo woman in the world, I started trav-
eling alone to Ireland, because travel—and solo travel
specifically—helped me question these ready-made narra-
tives that were so loud in my twenties, the expectations of
marriage and children and the life I was supposed to lead,
because that was just how it was done. What I loved most
about those early-aughts trips to Ireland—about learning
how to travel, why I wanted to travel, why I wanted to
travel alone, why movement itself felt important—was no-
ticing where my instinct to say yes faded into no and where
no expanded into why not? Traveling alone is a thing apart,
though, and traveling alone while female is another thing
entirely. On my study abroad in 2000 when I was twen-
ty-one, without any of those skills in place, I brought a
huge hiker’s backpack so comically big and heavy that I
couldn’t lift it into the overhead compartment by myself,
with two giant suitcases that barely fit in the trunk of the
taxi that would take us from the bus station to student
housing. It was my first real lesson in self-sufficiency, in
the style and determined enthusiasm of a toddler: I need to
do it by myself. When I returned in 2005, my pack was half
the size. In later years, I’ve gone even smaller just because
I like the challenge.
But a solo woman traveling has been handed a Holly-
wood-ish story framework, established tropes of how a woman
traveling alone must be afraid, or lost, or brash, or a lesbian,
or not a lesbian, or stuck, or unable to change a tire, or sexy
while skillfully changing a tire. The travel journey required of
women—as popularly presented—must be away from a love
interest, toward a love interest, toward healing, away from a
toxic environment, presumably toward a fuller understanding
of identity. So many of these stories are stories of escape, of
being in search of oneself or rediscovering oneself, but none
of those applied to me. I went alone, back to Ireland, for the
simple reason that I wanted to. What was I waiting for? A
very good question. I certainly didn’t travel to go find myself
because I’d never lost myself. It seemed an inherently silly
proposition. I wasn’t traveling in search of my identity or my
place in the world because my family had already built that. I
knew who I was, and I knew who I was in the context of my
family. Who I was as an individual, I’d constructed that with
my own hands, with the tools in my Craftsman tool bag that
had been a gift from my father.
Last New Year’s, he handed me a set of small Crafts-
man screwdrivers and said, Santa forgot one.
I grinned at him. Do they come with fully functional legs so
they can sprout and walk away from my tool bag, or do I have to
install them myself?—because it’s a running joke for our tools
to sprout legs and walk away so that we can never find them.
Dad grinned back. They come ready to go.
Fantastic, I said.
There are two types of stories common among families:
one tells the story of movement away—from pain, from a
life unwanted. The other is the movement toward—curios-
ity, adventure, making a name, separating yourself from an
established story and figuring out who you are outside of it.
There’s something compelling about bone-deep curiosity as
a reason for leaving and going elsewhere. There’s a reason
why the Odyssey is a story that can be retold on the streets
of Dublin or in the banjo twang of O Brother, Where Art
Thou? The best of these stories are roads on which we can
write our own experience. When I started to question the
path I’d been on and how it had created the person I saw
in the mirror in the morning, it felt natural to keep taking
steps backward even as my desire for travel moved me for-
ward. One step leads to another step, something the ancient
Chinese philosophers knew well, though I’d be surprised if
they had a road trip in mind. Maybe they did.
Five years later, two days after my thirty-fifth
birthday, my Minnesota grandmother Phyllis died, and
suddenly our family lost a bright guiding spark, a founda-
tional force. My grandfather Kermit had passed away in
2006, and our family of Minnesota Babines + my moth-
er’s parents, a solid little family of seven now reduced to
five, was shrinking in ways that felt deeper than simply the
loss of two people who were responsible for much of how
our little family functioned and what we valued. Now they
were both gone: Gram, who would recite the first stanzas
of James Russell Lowell’s “The First Snowfall” every time it
snowed, and Grandpa, who taught us how to know how old
a white pine is by counting its rings of branches.
Gram had left my sisters and me a little money, and it
seemed prudent to save it for something important.
You should take a trip, my sisters said at some point that
winter.
I could, but it feels frivolous.
Why? they asked. Gram loved to travel. She would have
loved to see you use it for that.
I guess that was true, even though it felt like I should
save it for a rainy day. I’d been in grad school living on a
pittance of a stipend, so spending money of any sort felt
vaguely wrong, but because of my financial situation, I’d
barely used my Scamp for a couple of years. If I were going
to go on a big Scamp trip, where would I go? What would be a
good use of this money that’s suddenly made things possible—
something that would make Gram look at me, smile that proud
smile, and nod her head like she would do?
I decided to point the Jeep and Scamp in the direc-
tion of my father’s family, east toward Nova Scotia and the
Canadian Maritimes. That’s where the Babines, who were
French-Acadian, came from back in the early days of Acadie
in the 1620s, before le Grand Dérangement in 1755, when the
English deported more than ten thousand French Acadians
from the place they called Acadie, dumped them on ships
bound for anywhere else, and the British renamed it Nova
Scotia. I didn’t know if this trip to Nova Scotia would turn
out to be anything more than accumulating miles and new
souvenir keychains, maybe discovering an affection for some
geographically specific food that would spark nostalgia every
time a certain pattern of weather crosses my day, but I think
there was a part of me that didn’t care which way I went,
because I just wanted to do something. I was feeling restless
about staying put too long.
As the family historian, I spend a lot of time wondering
about the stories we can tell, the ethics of storytelling, of
family secrets, of family pain, things that are not exactly
secret, but things we choose not to talk about anyway? For
some it might be an intellectual question—or not even a
question at all—but for me, it’s a really important question.
The storyteller, the family historian, holds immense power
and I feel the need to be careful, because stories aren’t neu-
tral. What I do with them will echo.
As I planned the trip, I taped quotes from W. Scott
Olsen above my computer as I calculated miles and stopping
points: “There is a pull to the universe, an insistent some-
thing that calls us out, then across. On the road, there is
always the chance that the world will be unmade for us, then
remade larger,” and “What do we want from the viewed sur-
face of the earth, from the way the earth rises and falls away,
or doesn’t? What do our hearts tell us we need from the
shape of the land?” It felt good to read—and be reminded—
that I didn’t need to go elsewhere, to more important places,
to know something true and real. Growing up in rural
northern Minnesota, the only radio stations we could get
were country and it felt good to sing along to our stories
and lives, lakes and trees and dirt roads and Brad Paisley’s
“Ticks” and Dixie Chicks’ “Wide Open Spaces” and Lit-
tle Big Town’s “Boondocks,” music that celebrated the place
where we were, rather than the allure of elsewhere. I’ve lost
a lot of interest lately in contemporary country music with
women turned into objects and cruelty wrapped in patrio-
tism, preferring instead to turn on blues, or bluegrass, from
Trampled by Turtles to I’m With Her to Wailin’ Jennys and
Red Molly and let those strings set fire to the air in a way
that clears everything from here to the horizon. It feels good
to sing your place in the world sometimes.
With different colored highlighters, I marked locations
on the map from my family tree—Halifax, Yarmouth,
Grand-Pré—and then worked my way backward while also
working forward. At some point my lines would meet in
the middle. Leaving Minneapolis, Thunder Bay, Ontario,
seemed a good first-night stop, being about six hours away.
There weren’t any good places to stop between Thunder
Bay and Sault Ste. Marie, so I resigned myself to an eight-
hour drive. Sault Ste. Marie to Driftwood Provincial Park
in Stonecliffe, Ontario, then onto Quebec City, Quebec.
From there, Fredericton, New Brunswick, en route to
Fundy National Park, where I’d spend a couple of days be-
fore heading up to Prince Edward Island. I wouldn’t expect
to encounter anything Babine until I left Prince Edward
Island and headed for Halifax, but it seemed silly to get
that close to Anne of Green Gables and not visit. I’d spend
about ten days in Nova Scotia, then to Kennebunk, Maine,
where the Babines settled for only a generation and a half
before the family split and my great-grandparents headed
for California. It would take me about four days from there
to get back to Minnesota.
There are stories of women traveling, but few of them
are road trips. We have early travel narratives by ship, tales
of settler women making their way across the Great Ameri-
can Desert in wagons, and countless stories of walking. The
road story of women is worth telling—and the camping
stories of solo women equally so. Camping alone is the only
time I have to be what feels like fully myself, fully immersed
in the solitude I seem to need to function best. When I tell
people I camp alone, so many wonder if I get lonely, but the
truth is that I almost never am. I might text wish you were
here to my family, and it’s just as easy to text friends a pic-
ture, and that seems to satisfy the need to share a moment
with another human being. I’m alone, I’m solitary—but I’m
not disconnected. My connections to people and the world
are vibrant and strong. I just like coming home to an empty
house where I can recharge my social battery in peace.
It feels deliberate and methodical, the way that I never
pursued permanent partnership or kids, and while I’m not
opposed to partnership, the act of changing my mind
would have to include significant effort. I have a house, a
job, and a full life. He’s not competing with other men to be
with me, I’d think—he’s competing with me, and I like my
life just the way it is. Even if our decisions are based in a
unique worldview, we make our choices out of curiosity, or
stubbornness, out of external societal pressure. Sometimes
I do things purely out of spite because I’m a Scorpio, but
I also think there’s a certain kind of stubbornness that is
less obstinate and more just a function of immovability,
the work of simply never changing course, and getting
where you want to go simply because you never considered
another option, never considered that the thing would not
happen. It’s a kind of stamina, the work of constructing
a life by playing the long game, which requires a certain
kind of emotional and mental endurance. It’s not stub-
bornness, but that’s the closest language I have.
The Scamp fell into this mindset too. I couldn’t be
talked into buying a camper that would sleep two or more
people comfortably or that would fit a dog I didn’t have. I
always wanted the Scamp, way back at the beginning, back
when we’d occasionally see them when we went camping
when I was young, and it never occurred to me to choose a
different camper—or even that I wouldn’t have one at some
point in my life. It was a kind of inevitability that didn’t
feel so much stubborn, as of course it is. If Mr. Right ever
showed up, we’d renegotiate the camper situation—in the
meantime, I wasn’t going to live my life for somebody who
may or may not ever exist. Even then, I might still keep the
Scamp and go camping by myself.
When I’m at home, wherever home is, and the Scamp is
parked in the driveway, sometimes I’ll go out there, close the
door behind me, lay down on the bed, and just take a deep
breath. There’s something elementally comforting about the
interior shape of this tiny camper, how it feels so much larger
on the inside than it does from the outside, something I as-
sume has to do with the curved shape. When the world is
just a little bit too much, I discard the shell of my house and
take on the shell of the camper and let it form the physical
barrier between me and the world, especially in times when
what holds me together feels fragile, my skin feels thin, when
my self feels like you could see through me. It’s not a matter
of spending time in the camper to remember who I am, but
rather a matter of being reminded of the deliberate choices
I’ve made to live my life the way I want to.