Undergraduates frequently encounter Plato through the Apology. But how does one move from impressions of this exceptional dialogue to philosophical and historical scholarship? This fine anthology, from a 2015 conference in Bergen, Norway, supplies this pedagogical need. The 11 essays survey cruxes of the dialogue that Gro Rørstadbotten (in his essay "Socrates's Telling of the Truth") calls the "point zero," where Plato's Socrates meets his historical counterpart. Most essays problematize Socrates himself. Arlene Saxonhouse sees tensions between democracy and "shameless" speech (parrhesia). Other contributors link Socrates's rhetoric to history. Rørstadbotten reviews the amnesty law that prohibited litigious reference to the atrocities of the oligarchy. Hallvard Fossheim faults Socrates regarding Aristotle’s account of virtue—Socrates's cleverness, poverty, and lack of straightforward political engagement compromise practical wisdom. The eminent Paul Woodruff argues that Socrates's exhortation to Athens is strange unless understood as a call to jurors "to examine themselves and live in accordance with human limitations." Such insights supplement those in previous works on either the broader philosophy of Socrates (e.g., Thomas Brickhouse and Nicholas Smith's The Philosophy of Socrates, CH, Jul'00, 37-6200) or on his rhetoric (I. F. Stone's The Trial of Socrates, CH, Nov'88, 26-1493).

Summing Up: Recommended. Lower-division undergraduates through faculty.

CHOICE

In Plato’s Apology of Socrates we see a philosopher in collision with his society—a society he nonetheless claims to have benefited through his philosophic activity. It has often been asked why democratic Athens condemned a philosopher of Socrates' character to death. This anthology examines the contribution made by Plato’s Apology of Socrates to our understanding of the character of Socrates as well as of the conception of philosophy Plato attributes to him. The 11 chapters offer complementary readings of the Apology, which through their different approaches demonstrate the richness of this Platonic work as well as the various layers that can be discerned in its presentation of Socrates. While the contributions display variety in both topics and angles, they also share common features: An awareness of the importance of the literary aspects of Plato’s courtroom drama, as well as a readiness to take into consideration the historical context of the work. Thereby they provide contributions to a manifold understanding of the aims and impact of the work, without losing sight of the philosophical questions that are raised by Socrates’ confrontational and unrepentant defense speech. Allowing the character of Socrates to take center stage, the chapters of this volume examine the philosopher in relation to ethics, and to politics and democracy, as well as to the ideology, religion, and virtue shared by the Athenians. Readers will also find reflections on classical Platonic subjects such as the nature of Socratic philosophical inquiry and of philosophy itself, as well as on the notoriously ambiguous relationships between philosophy, sophistry and rhetoric, and their several relationships to truth and justice. The anthology emphasizes and explores the equivocal and sometimes problematic aspects of Socrates as Plato presents him in the Apology, illuminating why the Athenians let the verdict fall as they did, while drawing out problematic features of Athenian society and its reaction to Socrates’ philosophic activity, thereby encouraging reflection on the role philosophy can play in our modern societies.
Les mer
Introduction Chapter 1: A Shameless Socrates on Trial in Democratic Athens Arlene Saxonhouse Chapter 2: Philosophy, Democracy and Poverty: The Philosopher as Political Agent in Plato’ Apology Oda Tvedt Chapter 3: The Temporality of Philosophy in the Apology Kristin Sampson Chapter 4: Plato’s Socrates in the Apology: Speaking in Two Voices Knut Ågotnes Chapter 5: Socrates’ Daimonic Ethics: Myth and Heroism in Plato’s Apology Jacob Howland Chapter 6: Plato’s Apologies Gro Rørstadbotten Chapter 7: The Character of Socrates in Plato’s Apology: An Aristotelian Analysis Hallvard Fossheim Chapter 8: Socrates’ Failure: Language and Lies in Plato’s Apology Olof Pettersson Chapter 9: Self-Images of Socrates. Respect for Tradition and Critical Examination in Plato’s Apology Elena Irrera Chapter 10: Socrates’ Mission Paul Woodruff Chapter 11: The Philosophical Force of Negativity: Elenchos and Socratic Conversation in Plato’s Apology Vivil Valvik Haraldsen
Les mer

Produktdetaljer

ISBN
9781498549998
Publisert
2017-12-28
Utgiver
Vendor
Lexington Books
Vekt
567 gr
Høyde
237 mm
Bredde
159 mm
Dybde
24 mm
Aldersnivå
P, UP, 06, 05
Språk
Product language
Engelsk
Format
Product format
Innbundet
Antall sider
256

Biographical note

Vivil Valvik Haraldsen is lecturer at the University of Bergen. Olof Pettersson is research fellow at Uppsala University. Oda E. W. Tvedt researches history of philosophy at Uppsala University.