John Haffenden is calm and accepting in his account of Empson's private life.
John Batchelor, Modern Language Review
John Haffenden's monumental two-volume biography leaves us in no doubt of the importance of Empson's upbringing as a scion of Yorkshire gentry...One of the big achievements of Haffenden's narrative is the painstaking account of Empson's gradual maturation as a critic.
Jason Harding, Essays in Criticism
Haffenden's narrative is driven along with such gusto, such alert intelligence, such obvious pleasure in the task, that no one could reasonably grumble at the story's inordinate length. It is a virtuoso feat of scholarship: a telling demonstration of what biography, as it finest, can actually achieve.
Ian Donaldson Australian Book Review
This is scholarship in the grand style
Contemporary Poetry Review
Biography is a dominant form these days, and Haffenden's is one of the best.
Fred Inglis, The Independent (Review)
The culmination of a majestic achievement
Mark Bostridge, Independent on Sunday
This is a definitive work, brimming with dry humour, acute political and literary analysis and a quiet respect for Empson's defining idiosyncrasies.
Tim Martin, Telegraph
His two-volume Empson now ranks, with say, Holmes on Coleridge. McCarthy on Morris, Bellos on Perec, Ellman on Joyce and Wilde: it is one of the great literary biographies.
Kevin Jackson, Sunday Times Culture
It would be high enough praise to say that Haffenden has equalled the achievement of his first volume; the reality is that he has excelled it.
Kevin Jackson, Sunday Times Culture
Haffenden has given us an Empson we should be arguing about, and arguing with, well into the future.
Peter McDonald, Literary Review
Impressive.
Andrew Motion, The Guardian
Resolutely unhysterical, affectionately written and delightfully incisive.
Tim Martin, Daily Telegraph
Magisterial biography.
Tim Martin, Daily Telegraph
Immense and magnificent biography
Frank Kermode, London Review of Books
[A] superlative work
Eric Griffiths
Haffenden's collection of material and mastery of the mass of published and unpublished documents is exemplary...Taken together his two volumes give a splendid sense of their subject, and of the literary, intellectual and political milieux in which Empson worked.
David Fuller, The Review of English Studies, Volume 58, Number 237