... elegantly-written, with complex exegetical work, philosophical discussion, and historical scholarship woven neatly into an admirably clear and readable whole.
Sabrina Little, Journal of Moral Philosophy
an important book that all scholars interested in Nietzsche's views on mind and agency will need to study carefully.
Journal of Nietzsche Studies
For anyone teaching a seminar on Nietzsche or the history of moral psychology, I can recommend without reservation putting The Nietzschean Self on your syllabus. It may be possible to write a better book on Nietzsches moral psychology, but no one has done so yet.
British Journal for the History of Philosophy
The book is clear and engaging. Katsafana's makes judicious use of concepts and theories from more recent philosophical psychology to illuminate Nietzsche's views, and he offers detailed, insightful discussions of relevant secondary literature.
Mind
this volume deserves to be read seriously by all those with an interest in Nietzsche and moral psychology.
Ethics
The picture Katsafanas offers is compelling, well articulated, and well defended. The book adds to our understanding of several timely debates, and thus should be read by anyone interested in Nietzsche's moral psychology.
Dialogue
...well organized and clearly written, and some of the interpretive theses Katsafanas advocates present an intriguing countercurrent to some of the most popular views in contemporary Nietzsche scholarship.
Karl Laderoute, Journal of the History of Philosophy