This is a very good book. Well written, judicious, thoroughly researched, with generous acknowledgements to the work of others in the field, the book might be thought to be a work of synthesis. It is in fact much more. It brings a new perspective to the on-going debate on the English Reformation, tells the reader much that is new on the doctrinal shifts that took place, and places it all in the context of social and cultural movement.

theological book review

This is a book that is a pleasure to read and will appeal to many a general reader who is tempted to pick it up; its style is accessible, its argument clear. It goes without saying that is has much to teach undergraduates, graduates and even teachers of the English Reformation.

theological book review

... its implications go far beyond the circumscribed academic field of "death studies", and it will be essential reading for all students of the social and cultural history of the Reformation.

Arnold Hunt, Times Literary Supplement

Se alle

... intricately structured and carefully researched ... Marshall is remorselessly honest and eclectic in his choice of examples, and the result is a fascinating web of intersecting themes and personalities. There is already a large literature on this subject, but this is the overview which we have needed to make sense of the bewildering detail.

Archive for Reformation History

How people in early modern England thought they could relate to the dead is the subject of Peter Marshall's insightful and luminously written Beliefs and the Dead in Reformation England.

The Way

... excellent ... valuable addition to the literature ... Marshall's book is the study of a central theme of peoples' lives in medieval England and how they coped with its disappearance. This elevates his book in importance and places it in the category of one of the most important books in religious history to have been written in the last two decades. It will be an indispensable book for students of the Reformation and for the religious life of England after the Reformation.

H-Albion

An admirable treatment of a neglected subject ... This is a book with a wide compass and a wealth of interesting topics ... the research is exhaustive, the writing clear and attractive, and the judgements wise.

Church Times

masterly scholarship and measured judgement.

Folk Life, Volume 44

This is the first comprehensive study of one of the most important aspects of the Reformation in England: its impact on the status of the dead. Protestant reformers insisted vehemently that between heaven and hell there was no 'middle place' of purgatory where the souls of the departed could be assisted by the prayers of those still living on earth. This was no remote theological proposition, but a revolutionary doctrine affecting the lives of all sixteenth-century English people, and the ways in which their Church and society were organized. This book illuminates the (sometimes ambivalent) attitudes towards the dead to be discerned in pre-Reformation religious culture, and traces (up to about 1630) the uncertain progress of the 'reformation of the dead' attempted by Protestant authorities, as they sought both to stamp out traditional rituals and to provide the replacements acceptable in an increasingly fragmented religious world. It also provides detailed surveys of Protestant perceptions of the afterlife, of the cultural meanings of the appearance of ghosts, and of the patterns of commemoration and memory which became characteristic of post-Reformation England. Together these topics constitute an important case-study in the nature and tempo of the English Reformation as an agent of social and cultural transformation. The book speaks directly to the central concerns of current Reformation scholarship, addressing questions posed by 'revisionist' historians about the vibrancy and resilience of traditional religious culture, and by 'post-revisionists' about the penetration of reformed ideas. Dr Marshall demonstrates not only that the dead can be regarded as a significant 'marker' of religious and cultural change, but that a persistent concern with their status did a great deal to fashion the distinctive appearance of the English Reformation as a whole, and to create its peculiarities and contradictory impulses.
Les mer
A study of one of the most important aspects of Reformation in England: its impact on the status of the dead. This book explores attitudes towards the dead in pre-Reformation religious culture, and traces the uncertain progress of the 'reformation of the dead' attempted by the Protestant authorities.
Les mer
Introduction ; 1. The Presence of the Dead: Memory and Obligation before the Reformation ; 2. Debates over the Dead: Purgatory and Polemic in Henrician England ; 3. 'Rage against the Dead': Reform, Counter-Reform, and the Death of Purgatory ; 4. The Regulation of the Dead: Ritual and Reform in the English Church, c.1560-1630 ; 5. The Estate of the Dead: The Afterlife in the Protestant Imagination ; 6. The Disorderly Dead: Ghosts and their Meanings in Reformation England ; 7. Remembering the Dead: Commemoration and Memory in Protestant Culture ; Conclusion ; Bibliography of Printed Primary Sources ; Index
Les mer
Review from other book by this author Peter Marshall's detailed and finely balanced examination of the English priesthood in the age of Reformation is a superb example of the fresh insights still to be found in this enduringly contentious area ... The precision and poise of this study means that we are provided not only with an account of the priesthood but also with a fascinating and delicately-constructed picture of the wider English religious scene between c. 1500 and 1553 ... One of the greatest strengths of this work is the way in which it manages to quell the more strident voices of polemicists both past and present and let us hear the faint, at times almost inaudible, voices of ordinary people ... In both its wider perspective and its detailed perception, this work offers a rare level of insight. The disputatious world of Reformation history stands very much in need of this type of approach to balance the equally necessary, but more argumentative, works on this subject. Ecclesiastical History `major contribution to revisionist historical literature on the English Reformation ... Marshall works his way through wills, ecclesiastical court documents, churchwardens' accounts, and the results of episcopal visitations with great balance, skill, and sophistication. Another major contribution of Marshall's work is his analysis of anticlericalism.' Church History `An original and richly detailed study of the parochial priesthood in the English church from Henry VII to the Protestant Edward VI.' Religious Studies Review `Marshall's interesting and well-documented study enhances our knowledge of lay attitudes' Albion `a readable, historically sound and well-balanced study which constitutes a valuable contribution to our understanding of the early English Reformation.' Theological Book Review `a judicious book. Marshall deftly steers the reader through a wide range of sources...We emerge... with an enlarged perception of prevailing platitudes as well as changing attitudes.' Times Literary Supplement `makes a scholarly and nuanced contribution to the debate... Dr Marshall has produces an impressive analysis of the attitudes of early Tudor parishioners to their priests which does indeed, as he intended, 'illuminate something of the nature of "popular religion" in the early sixteenth century, and the impact of reform on the interaction of the ordinary Christian and his pastor'.' English Historical Review
Les mer
Shortlisted for the Longman/History Today award 2003
Major new contribution to the understanding of Reformation mentalities and beliefs Includes compelling analysis of the cultural meanings of ghosts in sixteenth-century England
Major new contribution to the understanding of Reformation mentalities and beliefs Includes compelling analysis of the cultural meanings of ghosts in sixteenth-century England

Produktdetaljer

ISBN
9780198207733
Publisert
2002
Utgiver
Oxford University Press
Vekt
645 gr
Høyde
242 mm
Bredde
162 mm
Dybde
26 mm
Aldersnivå
P, 06
Språk
Product language
Engelsk
Format
Product format
Innbundet
Antall sider
356

Forfatter