Paddock makes an important empirical contribution through his textual analysis by demonstrating the pervasiveness of negative images in of Russia in the pre-war public sphere. Scholars will find particularly interesting his chapters analyzing the German press. . . . Paddock's work is likely to appeal to specialists in German-Russian relations and scholars interested in the variety of German orientalisms.
FIRST WORLD WAR STUDIES
[A] very useful book . . . .
INTERNATIONAL HISTORY REVIEW
The book's main argument-that the image of Russia created by German historians and journalists was largely a foil for their own concerns about Germany, their re?ection in a panoptic mirror -- is sharp and illuminating. It is commendable that, rather than writing a purely intellectual history, Paddock traces the transmission of this image from experts to school textbooks and the press.
AMERICAN HISTORICAL REVIEW
Students of this period of German history will find this new book a welcome addition to existing research. It provides the broader context of the stereotypes concerning Russia which can be found throughout German literature and correspondence of the pre-war era.
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF HISTORY
Paddock's study shines . . . in its discussion of how prewar [German views of Russia] provide insight into their promoters' self-image and values . . . . The 'myth of [Russian] organic unity' [is] illuminated intriguingly by Paddock . . . .
GERMAN STUDIES REVIEW