Bill Jenkins masterfully explores a brilliant era for science in Scotland [...] Jenkins's excellent book significantly helps us to better understand Darwin, while still being a tribute to the brilliant Scottish civic and scientific culture of the early 19th century, to the characters who forged it, and to the open-minded institutions that made it possible.
- José Carlos Sánchez-González, University of Oviedo, Centaurus
Jenkins has introjected new life and meaning into the existing body of scholarship and greatly enriched our understanding of this critical place and period in the history of evolution theory.
- Evelleen Richards, Isis
A well-written and very interesting read and an important contribution to the historiography of (British) evolutionism.
- Koen B. Tanghe, University of Gent, Journal of the History of Biology
[...] a well-written and very interesting read and an important contribution to the historiography of (British) evolutionism.
- Koen B. Tanghe, University of Gent, Journal of the History of Biology