history doesn't get any better
Benjamin Schwarz, The Atlantic Monthly
a tremendous achievement, demonstrating mastery over half a dozen fields of scholarship.
David Abulafia, THES
It raises the bar for all future discussion of large-scale historical change, and not just for this period, but it also shows us how we may occasionally scramble over it.
TLS
Combining close documentary analysis with the latest archaeological research, it is extraordinarily ambitious and wide-ranging, and one of the great scholarly achievements of the year.
Dominic Sandbrook, The Daily Telegraph
The reader will not only learn an immense amount but constantly and actively engage both with the material and the arguments of this tremendously rich book.
John Hudson, BBC History
Wickham's work is groundbreaking ... Some of his conclusions may and should be debated, but they rest on an array of evidence and on a series of complex atguments that further discussions should not ignore.
Walter Pohl, Speculum
a magisterial study
Medium Aevum, Vol. LXXV