The book is a wealth of comprehensive research with a substantial number of areas of interest to family and community historians as well as to those with general interest in social history.
Helen Johnston, University of Hull, Family & Community History, Vol. 26/2
The amount of research that has fed into this book is indeed impressive; the wealth of data - some of which is presented in extensive appendices at the back of the volume - will be an essential resource for anybody studying penal and educational history for years to come.
Anne Schwan, Culture and Social History
Ultimately it is these vivid examples, along with the meticulous footnotes, charts and tables, primary sources such as prison inspector reports, as well as detailed appendices,that render this an indispensable volume. The book's geographical boundaries make sense, and yet the mentions of Irish prisons, references to prisoner transportation, andfascinating material on women prisoners invite other scholars potentially to expand on this exciting research. In this invaluable contribution to the history of education in the nineteenth century, we are haunted by the past and also by the challenges that persist-as today's prisoners remind us-in the present.
Sheila Cordner, Victorian Studies
Crone has written an impressively researched, nuanced, and well-argued book thatdeserves to be read widely and should be essential reading for historians of education and those interested in penal history. Victorianists and social historians will also find in it much that is worthwhile. The book's eclectic visual sources, including images of prison registers and classrooms, enliven its often-hefty empirical analysis and textual thickets, while offering the reader a more vivid understanding of the topic. The copious notes and tables in the book's appendices amount to an invaluable resource and reference guide that will be of interest to both scholars and students wishing to research this topic further.
Petros Spanou, Journal of British Studies