It is only when the allusive economy of the prose is contrasted with the massive apparatus of footnote references that one appreciates to the full not just the author's formidable learning but also the self-restraint and disciplined care with which he chose his lines of enquiry.
Parliamentary History
A thoughtful and thought-provoking book ... a consolidated, must-read, research agenda which will keep us going for some time.
Continuity and Change
Represents a topping-off of one of the most distinguished current careers in the writing of social history ... an overview of social policy as a whole over the same period, at national and local level, weaving his research into that of the whole range of publications made in the field over the past thirty years. The lecture format is well used, each chapter tackling a discrete issue, while the conclusion provides a genuine judgement on the whole, one of conspicuous power and importance. Although he never labours the point himself, the contemporary relevance of Slack's study, representing the previous history of public welfare policy at a time when the present structure is increasingly endangered, is obvious.
Ronald Hutton, Times Literary Supplement
These three themes add up to a wonderfully rich and convincing body of work ... From Reformation to Improvement hammers another nail into the coffin of economic determinism and argues powerfully for the primacy of ideology in driving human affairs ... a disturbing, as well as an exciting and important, book.
Ronald Hutton, Times Literary Supplement