A sumptuous book that is copiously annotated and immensely rewarding for the reader...This anthology is as rich, if not richer, than any single tafsir work in the original Arabic, and provides an unparalleled journey through the entire gamut of Qur'anic commentaries. I eagerly await the next volume.
Scott C. Lucas. Journal of Shi'a Islamic Studies.
A remarkable and unique contribution to the field of Qur'anic research and scholarship in English language...I recommend this book to all students and scholars of the Qur'an.
Muhammad Khan. The Muslim News
Notwithstanding its modest title of being an "anthology", it is massive scholarly feat which covers vast ground... The editors' selection of the commentators is wide-ranging and representative, enabling as it does readers to gain acquaintance with diverse strands of thought and sectarian perspectives. It is quite impressive to encounter a multiplicity of approaches, mindsets, sectarian considerations, and tools and strategies at work in the numerous attempts to arrive at the meaning of the Qur'án... The volume is an epitome of solid scholarship
Abdur Raheem Kidwai, The Muslim World Book Review
Hamza, Rizvi and Mayer have set a very high standard for annotated translations of Qur'anic commentaries and their labour deserves the highest praise...provides an unparalleled journey through the entire gamut of Qur'anic commentaries. I eagerly await the next volume.
Scott C. Lucas, Journal of Shi's Islamic Studies.
superb collection ... Over and above the consistently high quality of the individual contributions, a major strength of Suleman's collection is its breadth of chronological and geographic coverage ... With a useful glossary, and generous bibliography, this volume definitely belongs in all university libraries supporting comprehensive art history, comparative religion, and Islamic Studies programs.
John Renard, Religion and the Arts
a significant advance in the burgeoning field of Tafsir studies ... This anthology is the resuly of a careful process of deliberation and insightful judgements. The meticulousness of the editors is apparent in every aspect of the book. The selections are extensive, the translations read well and are faithful to the Arabic original.
Walid A. Saleh, Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies
[a] superbly presented and valuable effort
Gibril Fouad Haddad, Journal of Islamic Studies