This is an impressive achievement. In addition to providing us with a much needed account of Iranian criminal law and criminal justice, Khodadadi also develops the concept of theocratic criminal law to analyse the combination of religious beliefs, constitutional doctrine and politics that has shaped contemporary Iranian criminal law. This is an important contribution both to comparative criminal law and to criminal law theory.
Lindsay Farmer, University of Glasgow
Bahman Khodadadi's courageous, interdisciplinary, wide-ranging, and precise work uses a case study, the Islamic Republic of Iran, to demonstrate a theocratically based, yet formally modern legal system as an ideal-typical counter-model to the liberal rule of law. He shows what functions a theocratic and thus ultimately totalitarian criminal law, which aims to equate crime with sin, assumes as an instrument of domination and discipline - a great and important book.
Thomas Gutmann, University of Münster
A fascinating, historically informed, critical analysis of Iran's theocratic criminal law. Khodadadi explores its grounding in a theocratic constitution, and its uneasy relationship with ideas of human rights and the rule of law. He provides readers with an illuminating introduction to a criminal law that will be alien to many; he illustrates the political foundations of criminal law, and the different forms that it can therefore take.
Antony Duff, University of Stirling
Bahman Khodadadi's book, On Theocratic Criminal Law: the Rule of Religion and Punishment in Iran, is a ground-breaking book. Eschewing both sensationalism and apology, Khodadadi's book approaches the criminal justice system in the Islamic Republic of Iran systematically, both from the internal perspective of the theological, juridical and ideological premises of the Islamic Republic of Iran, and the external perspective of liberal legal theory.
Prof. Mohammad Fadel, University of Toronto
The idea of a constitutional theocracy might seem oxymoronic to some, but Khodadadi offers a thoughtful and subtle study of the ways in which Iran's theocracy - like many other authoritarian systems - uses constitutionalism and law to deepen its ideological and institutional hold on the society it governs. Through meticulous research on the Islamic Republic's criminal law system, he provides an original and insightful analysis of the role criminal law (and punishment) as a central mechanism in maintaining theocratic domination... The book makes a major contribution towards our understanding of the development of the post-revolutionary Iranian legal system and offers a revealing critical analysis of the contradictions shot through Iran's principle of legality.
Prof. Asli Bali, Yale University